How Does My Underinsured Motorist Coverage Pay in Illinois After a Crash?
Tue 17 Nov, 2026 / by Robert Parker / Car Accidents, Uninsured / Underinsured Motorist Claims
Published: November 17, 2026
In Illinois, underinsured motorist coverage, called UIM, applies when the other driver’s liability limit is lower than your UIM limit. Your insurer pays up to your UIM limit minus what you actually collected from the other driver’s insurer under 215 ILCS 5/143a-2, never more than your actual damages. Give your insurer written notice before you accept the other driver’s offer.
The other driver’s adjuster offered the whole policy, and your hospital bill is already larger than the offer. Does your own insurance pay the rest? Underinsured motorist coverage can pay toward it, when your UIM limit is higher than the other driver’s limit. The order matters: read your declarations page, give your insurer written notice before you accept anything, then make the UIM claim. If you are calling for someone still in the hospital, you can make the first call to our office for them.
What is underinsured motorist coverage in Illinois, and do I have it?
Underinsured motorist coverage is coverage under your own auto policy for a crash caused by a driver whose liability insurance is smaller than your UIM limit. Every Illinois auto policy carries uninsured motorist coverage, called UM, under 215 ILCS 5/143a. Unless you turned the higher amount down in writing, UM matches the liability limits you bought to cover injuries you might cause to others. If your UM limit is above the state minimum, your policy also carries UIM in the same amount. Your declarations page, the summary page that lists your coverages and their amounts, shows the number.
As of 2026, Illinois requires liability coverage of at least $25,000 per injured person and $50,000 per crash under 625 ILCS 5/7-203. Our post on Illinois car insurance requirements lists the required amounts, and our post on what full coverage actually covers in Illinois explains declarations-page labels. If you were a passenger, our post on UM and UIM coverage for passengers in Illinois explains where that coverage can come from.
When does UIM apply?
UIM applies when the other driver’s liability limit, the most that driver’s policy pays for the injuries the driver caused, is lower than your own UIM limit. The comparison is limit to limit. If the other driver’s limit equals or exceeds yours, UIM does not apply, no matter how large your losses are. The statute adds up the limits of every liability policy covering the other driver and the vehicle before it makes that comparison.
Suppose you carry $100,000 in UIM and the other driver carries $25,000. UIM applies. Suppose your UIM limit is $50,000 and the other driver carries $50,000. UIM does not apply, whatever your injuries cost.
How much does my own insurer pay?
The most your insurer pays is your UIM limit minus what you actually collected from the other driver’s insurer. The total from both sources can never exceed your actual damages, meaning what your injuries actually cost you. Take a $100,000 UIM limit and $50,000 collected from the other driver. That leaves up to $50,000 in UIM, if your damages reach that far.
Now suppose the other driver carried the 2026 minimum of $25,000 and you carry $100,000 in UIM. You collect the $25,000. Your own insurer then owes up to $75,000 more, and only up to what your injuries are actually worth once the $25,000 is counted. The subtraction uses the amount you actually received, even when the other driver’s limit was higher than the settlement. When several injured people share one liability limit, what counts against your UIM is what you actually received.
What happens first: the other driver’s insurance or mine?
The steps run in this order under 215 ILCS 5/143a-2:
- The claim against the other driver. The driver’s insurer handles it, and the most that insurer pays is the policy limit.
- Written notice to your own insurer. You tell your insurer in writing about the proposed settlement before you accept it.
- Your insurer’s 30-day choice. It can pay you that same amount itself within 30 days and keep its right to go after the other driver. If it does not, it gives that right up.
- The UIM claim under your own policy. Your policy may delay payment until the other driver’s coverage is paid out, in whole or in part.
Illinois allows a policy clause that delays UIM payment until the other driver’s coverage has been paid out by settlement or judgment. Your policy may also require your insurer’s written consent before you settle, so read it before you sign. Taking less than the other driver’s full limit does not, by itself, end your UIM claim. Illinois law says so. Even so, get advice before you accept, because the notice rules still apply and the settlement papers can affect your insurer’s rights against the other driver.
Two adjusters are calling: which one do I have to talk to?
Two adjusters may call, sometimes from the same company. One is handling the other driver’s claim. The other is acting as your own insurer under your policy. The rules for each call are different. You do not owe the adjuster handling the other driver’s claim a recorded statement, the adjuster’s recorded interview with you about the crash and your injuries. Get advice before you give one.
Requests from your own insurer are different. Your policy has cooperation duties: proof of the claim, medical authorizations, and sometimes an examination under oath, a formal interview under oath that is recorded. Refusing can put the UIM claim at risk. Get advice before you refuse or answer, and have a lawyer with you at any examination.
Does fault still matter when I claim under my own policy?
Yes. UIM pays when you are legally entitled to recover from the other driver, so the other driver’s fault still decides the claim. Under 735 ILCS 5/2-1116, if you were more than 50 percent at fault, there is no recovery; at 50 percent or less, the amount is reduced by your share.
What about medical payments coverage?
Medical payments coverage, if your policy has it, can pay early bills without regard to fault. Some policies then subtract what medical payments already paid from the UIM payment. Whether yours does depends on its wording, so bring the whole policy, not just the declarations page.
Can I add my UIM limits together across my cars?
Many policies do not let you add UIM limits together across your vehicles or across household policies; the policy language controls. Paying separate premiums does not by itself change that. Illinois lets insurers write that limit into the policy, and courts enforce clear clauses.
What if my insurer and I disagree about fault or the amount?
Once your insurer agrees the coverage applies, a disagreement over fault or over what your injuries are worth goes to arbitration when your policy provides for it. Arbitration is a hearing before neutral decision makers instead of a jury. Whether the policy covers the crash at all is ordinarily a question for a court. Many policies let either side reject a larger award and ask for a trial, so the policy’s own words decide how final the award is.
Is it too late to make a UIM claim?
The claim against the other driver generally has a two-year deadline under 735 ILCS 5/13-202. Your own policy sets its own notice and time limits for the UIM claim, and they can be shorter. Call before you decide it is too late, and bring the policy so its dates can be read.
What is the next step?
Find the declarations page, then call before you accept anything from the other driver’s insurer. Bring what you have: your declarations page, any letters from either insurer, the crash report or whatever you have on the other driver, and the medical bills so far. If you are calling for a family member, the same items help, and partial information is welcome. If you already signed anything, bring that too. If you wonder whether using your own coverage changes your rates, ask your agent and bring the answer.
The consultation is free. We charge a flat one-third contingency fee on personal injury cases, whether the case resolves before suit, after suit is filed, or at trial. No fee unless we win. Robert Parker personally handles every case the firm accepts, including UIM claims for injured people in Peoria, Tazewell, McLean, Knox and Woodford counties.
If the other driver’s policy ran out before your bills did, talk with our Peoria uninsured and underinsured motorist practice. We read every policy involved, handle both insurers, and work out what the claim is worth.
Call 309-673-0069 or use the contact page to set up a free consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to take the other driver’s whole policy when it will not cover my hospital bill?
No, the decision is yours, and the order of events matters. Before you accept, your own insurer gets written notice of the proposed settlement. It then has 30 days to pay you that amount itself and keep its rights against the other driver. The UIM claim under your own policy then goes forward if your UIM limit is higher than the other driver’s limit.
If I take their check, does my own insurance company pay the rest in Illinois?
Your own insurer pays up to your UIM limit minus the amount you collected, and never more than your actual damages. With a $100,000 UIM limit and $25,000 collected, the most UIM pays is $75,000, and only up to what your injuries are worth once the $25,000 is counted. Give your insurer written notice before you accept the offer or sign anything, because the sequence matters. If a check has already arrived, get advice before you cash it.
Whose side is the adjuster on when the same company insures both drivers in Illinois?
The same company can insure both drivers. On the call about the other driver’s claim, the adjuster is handling that claim for the other driver’s insurer, and you owe that adjuster no recorded statement. On the UIM claim, the company acts as your own insurer under your policy, and your policy’s cooperation duties apply. Ask which claim the call is about before you answer, and get advice first.
Do I have to give my own insurance company a statement or an examination under oath in Illinois?
Your own policy sets cooperation duties, which can include proof of the claim, medical authorizations and an examination under oath. Refusing can put the UIM claim at risk, so get advice before you refuse or answer, and have a lawyer with you at any examination.
Is it too late to make a UIM claim in Illinois?
Generally, the claim against the other driver has a two-year deadline under 735 ILCS 5/13-202. Your own policy sets its own, sometimes shorter, limits for the UIM claim, so call before you decide it is too late.
Related Articles
- Peoria UM/UIM Attorney: Uninsured and Underinsured Motorist Claims
- UM/UIM Coverage for Passengers in Illinois
- Illinois Car Insurance Requirements: Minimums, UM/UIM, and What You Really Need
- What “Full Coverage” Actually Covers in Illinois
For a free consultation about your injury case, contact our personal injury attorneys serving Central Illinois today.
