Skip to Content
Call or Text for a Free Consultation 309-673-0069

The Difficulties in International Adoption

Thu 5 Feb, 2015 / by / Adoption Law

Last Updated: November 12, 2026

International adoption can involve inconsistent legal systems, slow government processes, language barriers, and compliance costs. Country programs open, pause, and change over time, including for trafficking and Convention-compliance reasons. Treat older volume figures and country lists as dated discussion, confirm current State Department and USCIS country guidance, and work with an accredited agency and experienced counsel for the facts of your case.

Suprised baby

We were thrilled to complete a Haitian adoption recently, but in doing so became one of a very small – and shrinking – group of people in the U.S. to adopt internationally. In fact, as this piece first framed it around the March 2014 case and then-current State Department reporting, international adoptions had decreased by about half since 2003 – a historical roughly 50% cut in volume over that decade worldwide. Here in the U.S., adoptions had fallen over 60% during the same stretch, cresting near 23,000 in 2004-05, and the fiscal-year immigrant-visa counts around that period were in the neighborhood of 7,000 per year. Those decade-comparison figures are the article’s dated statistical framing, not a 2026 program census or proof that any one treaty caused the trend.

What do these percentages mean? In stark human terms, the original counterfactual in this post asked: if the 2004 level of international adoptions had been maintained, then about 92,000 more children would have had families during the last decade. That 92,000 figure is this article’s original rough counterfactual illustration from the 2015 publication looking back on that decade – not an independently reproduced calculation of an exact series, years, or method, and not a verified roster of known individual children without families. Using the 2010 Census Peoria MSA population of about 379,000 (reported in thousands), adding 92,000 is about 24.3% of that metro population, not nearly a doubling.

So why the downturn?

A few countries’ politics had a dampening effect, to be sure. Russian and Chinese adoptions fell in the first decade of the millenium (down 2,000 in 05-06 and 07-08; down 1,000 for 06-07 in those countries). In 2008-09 Guatemela closed all adoptions, leading to a Guatemalan drop of over 3,500 children. Other countries that, in this 2014-era discussion, were treated as closed or suspended for U.S. families included: Cambodia (closed since 2001 in that framing); Vietnam (U.S. processing treated as closed since 2008 in that framing – later official guidance is different: a December 31, 2020 joint announcement described expanded Vietnam Convention processing after a limited Special Adoption Program, so do not read the 2008 closure line as current blanket status); Kenya; Romania (since 2004); Cape Verde, Fiji, Montenegro, Rwana, Senegal...

all closed, in that historical U.S. view, because the U.S. considered them non-compliant. And there’s the rub: the U.S. itself had shut down some of the largest avenues of international adoption because of conditions in the country. Concerns about corruption, child-trafficking, and baby-selling prompted the US to suspend adoptions from Vietnam, Cambodia, Guatemala, and Nepal. And yet – taking Vietnam as the then-used example – despite that the US had shut down adoptions, other countries were still actively working there. In 2010 and 2011 about 2,000 adoptions still happened out of Vietnam, but none went to the US under that suspension. Prospective readers should check current official country information rather than treat this archive list as today’s worldwide status board.

So how do we balance these concerns? Clearly, preventing abuses is important, but at the same time, it can be argued that children are being left behind in these abusive countries when they’d be adopted out of them without the restrictions. Other countries continue to do so. The decline in international adoptions, and the restriction of certain countries, all appears tied – in the advocacy view we stated then – to the Hague Convention, which became more predominant over the same time period that adoptions have been dropping. Correlation in the historical series is not the same as a verified, all-country causal proof.

Don’t take our word for it: Chuck Johnson, CEO of the National Council of Adoption – click HERE for their website – contended that the decline comes from the way the State Department has applied the Hague Convention, which establishes ethical standards for international adoptions.

The U.S. entered into the agreement in 2008 with strong support from adoption advocates who hoped it would curtail fraud and corruption, and then lead to a boom in legitimate adoptions. Instead, the decrease has continued. “The U.S. has encouraged and in some cases strong-armed impoverished countries to sign the Hague Convention and then cites their inability to comply with strict Hague standards as a reason for not doing intercountry adoption with them,” Johnson said, as reported by the Associated Press on March 22, 2014 (Foreign adoptions by Americans decline sharply). That AP report matches the quotation and supports the dated U.S. near-7,000 / over-60% account (FY2013 7,094; FY2012 8,668; peak 2004 22,884). It does not prove universal Hague causation, authenticate a worldwide 50% series, or stand in for the original Fox or CNN pieces referenced below.

Other countries doing adoptions under Hague International law haven’t had the marked decline in numbers like the U.S. In other words, the problem is on our end, and we can lay these declining numbers at the State Department’s feet. For example, Brazil and Colombia are Hague members, and U.S. adoptions since 2003 have been under 250 per year from each country; meanwhile, other countries have adopted hundreds from Brazil and thousands (generally around 1,500) per year from Colombia.

The trouble is that the U.S. Central Authority (read: our liaison to facilitate Hague adoptions with other countries) doesn’t work proactively with those other countries to develop international adoption programs. We don’t play well with others. And we can certainly tell you that there’s a lot of red tape in doing a Hague adoption – much more than for non-Hague countries. Ultimately, children in need of families are penalized by our lack of government action.

Which brings us back to our recent adoption from Haiti. We completed the adoption on March 28, 2014. Haiti had signed the Hague Convention on Intercountry Adoption on March 2, 2011, and ratified it on December 16, 2013; April 1, 2014 was the Convention’s entry into force for Haiti – not the date Haiti first signed. We still acknowledge that we hastened, working as hard as we could, to complete this Haitian adoption before that entry-into-force date. Three days later, Convention procedures would have applied to new Convention cases, with more red tape and a different process. But a court-completion date alone does not create an automatic universal rule that every child already in the U.S. had to return abroad, or that every file became impossible. Treaty Article 2/28 concepts, habitual residence, Haitian origin-law requirements, the immigration route (including non-Convention transition categories that official Haiti guidance later described for certain pre–April 1, 2014 I-600A/I-600 / completed-adoption paths, subject to origin agreement and additional requirements), and the facts of the particular case all matter. Some non-Convention transition cases can finish after April 1, 2014. We are preserving the stated March 28, 2014 case account and counsel perspective – not adjudicating private eligibility, and not declaring that adoption invalid from a public summary.

In the Convention frame we feared then, completing the adoption in Haiti rather than here can mean being bound by Haitian timing and residence expectations while the case finishes. This was a child who previously had resided in an orphanage, together with many other children whose parents were not bad parents, but who could not afford to feed their children. An orphanage was the only way the children stood a chance to eat. So we are going to say that the child must go back there, for a year, year and a half, until the adoption completes? Where would the family be with whom the child had stayed for the last couple years, and how would they pay for flights, legal counsel, and an agency to complete the adoption?

It sounds like such a small thing, those 3 days, but they meant a lifetime, quite literally, to the child and her adoptive family. Presumably, the Hague is being brought to Haiti for good reasons: transparency, ethics in adoptions, preventing abuses. But like many best intentions and government programs, the reality it will bring may be much different.

If we had been brought that Haitian case just a couple days later, too, the Convention transition would have changed the pathway – even though, as noted above, not every later file is automatically impossible. Such as it is, we join these numbers, which are the amount of adoptions from Haiti to the U.S. in recent years past, drawn from State Department fiscal-year immigrant-visa-based annual-report tables (not a count of every child arrival):

2009: 330

2010 = 133

2011: 33

2012: 154

Those four values match the FY2009–2012 Haiti rows as read from the annual reports (finalized-abroad plus U.S.-finalization components). The FY2010 series excludes about 1,090 Haitian children who entered under special humanitarian parole and did not receive immigrant visas, so 133 is not “all Haitian child arrivals” that year. We wondered then: will this go near zero in the near future, with the arrival of Hague? That near-zero line was a dated 2014 counsel forecast/opinion, not a current prediction. Later fiscal-year visa tables continued to show Haiti activity in some years; none of these series prove, by themselves, that Hague caused every movement in the trend.

You often see the Hague being praised as a positive influence in adoption. Fox News’ press release on Haiti recently is here CLICK.; contrast that with CNN’s more in-depth look HERE (Click for article). While we don’t entirely criticize it, and certainly don’t criticize its goals, you may find it surprising and important to hear that the Hague has had side effects on international adoption as well, which haven’t been so positive.

Note: source of featured image is http://pwojeespwa.blogspot.com/2010/03/saturday-morning.html

Considering adoption?
This article is part of our Peoria Adoption Lawyer practice area.
Call Parker & Parker at 309-673-0069 for a free consultation.

Related Articles

Locations Map (KML)