Skip to Content
Call or Text for a Free Consultation 309-673-0069

Super Leading Top Lawyers: What’s in a Rating?

Thu 30 Jun, 2016 / by / Personal Injury

Last Updated: November 15, 2026

Leading Lawyers and Super Lawyers are peer-recognition lists, not client-rating scores and not one vendor algorithm. Super Lawyers names about 5% of lawyers in a state; Leading Lawyers names fewer than 5% in a state and category. Avvo’s 1-10 score is separate from client reviews. No single rating is definitive; reviews, referrals, and your own questions still matter.

confused workerHow do you find a lawyer these days in Illinois? We at Parker & Parker will be the first to admit it’s hard, for example, to find qualified and recommended doctors, house contractors, and tax pros. You want the job done well, fairly, and in a friendly manner. Where do you – where do we go – to find the right people in our community?

It’s confusing, no matter who you’re looking for. Answers are everywhere, but are they the right ones?

In the legal world, there’s an ever-increasing number of sites, certifications, awards, and claims by attorneys about who they are, what they do, and how well they do it. Where to turn?

Even if you’re looking at our site, you’ll see that we are proudly recognized by a number of organizations, honors, memberships, and online ranking systems. It’s in our letterhead and on this website. The original 2016 post referred to a banner on the letters we send; that banner image is not in this rendering and is not rebuilt here.

It’s a lot to go through, and you probably don’t even find all of the different places out there to look. So here’s where we go, and what we think they mean. Put another way, if we were looking for an attorney, this is a guide we’d follow in getting through information overload.

Honors

Super Lawyers and Leading Lawyers are respected in Illinois. Why? Other lawyers and even judges have recommended you. They’ve seen your work product, they’ve seen you in action in court, and and they’ve witnessed your legal abilities by interacting with you: you’re the cream of the crop. Super Lawyers names about 5% of lawyers in a state, using peer nominations, independent research (including verdicts and settlements among its 12 indicators), peer evaluation, and final selection. Informal client nominations can put a lawyer in the candidate pool, but they receive no nomination points. Leading Lawyers names fewer than 5% of Illinois attorneys in a state and category, using returned, weighted nominations and Advisory Board review. These honors are not an independent guarantee of case outcomes. They’re definitely a source of pride for attorneys, and if an attorney earns any of these distinctions, then you can bet they’re making it known, and rightfully so.

Drew Parker leading lawyer page

Professional Organizations

Memberships and organizations, such as the American Academy of Adoption Attorneys, have membership requirements that scrutinize experience, numbers and types of cases, reputation, ethics, and recommendations from members of the bar and personal references. The current application permits a judge reference; that is not a requirement that every fellow have a judicial endorsement. There are also local and state bar committees and positions; attorneys actively involved mean they know the community, help develop new laws, and generally recognize the importance of civic involvement and maintaining close ties to the community.

American Academy of Adoption Attorneys logo

Online Lawyer Locator Sites

Online sites, which are relatively new, like Avvo.com or Findlaw, collect professional memberships, awards, publications, peer endorsements, years of experience, and ethical records with the disciplinary commission (ARDC). Avvo’s 1-10 score is separate from client reviews. Avvo says client reviews are not a direct input into that score; peer endorsements can influence it. Paid Avvo advertising does not buy the numerical score. These sites do not all use one algorithm, and this is not a FindLaw-wide algorithm claim. They generally use information from the other sites above, but can still be helpful by showing feedback (beyond just the ranking) of past clients and other lawyers.

Robert Parker Avvo page

Social Media and General Information Sites

The digital world of social media, search engines, and directories are helpful but not automatically built to provide you with all the information you might need to pick an attorney. Google reviews are a great place to find reports of client experience. For better or worse, they are often the first and most prominent results displayed in response to Google searches. Also, many people don’t realize feedback can be left for attorneys – they’re more often used for restaurants, hotels, and other industries. Superpages, Lawyers.com, and other directories would fall into this category too.

review page

Many of these sites, like Avvo or even Google search results, will prioritize paying advertisers above everyone else in the area. It doesn’t mean any more or less, necessarily, about their true qualifications. That general sponsored-placement observation is separate from Avvo’s numerical score, which Avvo says paid services do not change.

Of course, there are personal pages, such as LinkedIn, Google+, Facebook, and Twitter. In 2016 this post listed Google+ as a personal-page example. Consumer Google+ closed April 2, 2019. Google Reviews, business listings, and other Google products are distinct and are not claimed closed here. And there’s always a firm’s own website, like this one, that can give you information straight from the horse’s mouth, which you can check against all the other sites above.

A firm website will show you what practice areas are important, they should have you a sense of what the law firm is like, and they often are the best source of biographical information. If an attorney doesn’t even have a website, then it’s Awords fair to draw your own conclusions about what that might mean.

Confused worker

With all the places you can look to research picking your lawyer, hopefully this article helps tell you where to start. The information is out there, in different ways and different places. The screenshots on this page are archival illustrations from the original 2016 period. Drew’s listed address and roles, and Avvo years-licensed, score, and review counts shown here, are not current certificates. And above all, if you have questions, don’t forget that you can always just ask us. We’re here to help. Most of all, that’s what a good attorney does.

Related Articles

Locations Map (KML)